BA (Hons) Journalism Dissertation
•
6th May 2014
How has the British performed its Fourth Estate in role in covering the Mark Duggan case?
The object of this dissertation is to study how the British Press has performed its Fourth Estate role in covering the Mark Duggan case. Mark Duggan was shot dead by a police officer in an ‘hard-stop’ operation in August 2011. His killing was, some argue, what sparked the riots which turned some deprived neighbourhood across the country in battlefields. To analyse how has the press performed its Fourth Estate role in reporting this case, the coverage has been analysed with the concepts of primary and secondary definers elaborated by Hall et al. in their ground-breaking book Policing the Crisis (1978). The analysis of the coverage revealed a fundamental bias of the majority of the British press towards the police, this was done through a marked use of anonymous police sources and through a “framing” of the image of Duggan, which was already evident soon after his death and did not change in the three years since. This study is significant because the Mark Duggan case is a vehicle through which it is possible to see how the press does not offer a fair representation to members of the ethnic minority communities in the press, especially if they have minor criminal convictions as in the case of Mr Duggan. Furthermore, it represents a failure of the idea of the press as a Fourth Estate, because throughout the coverage it is clear how the press never questioned or challenged a powerful institution of our society like the police, despite the contradictions which emerged during the inquest into Mr Duggan’s death. Despite the thirty-six years since its publication, Policing the Crisis, still proves to be correct in its finding of the press as reinforcing instead of challenging the status quo therefore not fulfilling its Fourth Estate role.